High-Risk US SMR Financing Puts Japanese Public Funds and Taxpayers in Jeopardy - Japanese and U.S. NGOs Issue Joint Statement Strongly Opposing Financing for 10 U.S. SMR Projects by JBIC and NEXI

Nuclear

Today, groups from Japan and the U.S. issued a joint statement strongly opposing financial support by the Japan Bank for International Cooperation (JBIC) and Nippon Export and Investment Insurance (NEXI) for ten small modular reactor (SMR) projects in the United States, totaling up to $40 billion (approx. 6 trillion yen). The statement questions  the economic rationale and repayment feasibility, and points out the violatations of  JBIC/NEXI’s Nuclear Public Disclosure Guidelines due to a lack of environmental impact assessments for 9 out of 10 projects.  The statment also highlighted serious environmental and social impacts along with public safety and waste management concerns. These financial deal was concluded based on trade tariff measures, however whose legal basis has already collapsed.

For the full text of the statement and a list of endorsing organizations, please see here.

Background and Context

On October 23, JBIC and NEXI listed 10 projects on ther list of projects under consideration for financial support: the Clinch River Nuclear Plant Units 1–5 in Tennessee and the Bellefonte Nuclear Plant Units 5–9 in Alabama, all of which are planned to utilize GE Hitachi Nuclear Energy’s “BWRX-300" SMR design. Both institutions can make decisions in as little as 45 days from public disclosure. These projects are included in the “second tranche" (approx. 10 trillion yen scale) of the total $550 billion (approx. 86 trillion yen)  Japan’s investment package for the U.S. agreed upon as a result of U.S.-Japan tariff negotiations.

Key Points of the Joint Statement

  1. Lack of Economic Rationale and Repayment Feasibility Questioned
    • The economic rationale for SMRs is questionable. Although advertised as “small and inexpensive," they tend to be more costly per unit of electricity generated than existing large-scale nuclear plants
    • NuScale Power’s prior SMR project in Idaho was forced to be canceled in November 2023 due to soaring construction costs. Investing in high-cost SMRs with uncertain prospects lacks business rationale, casting serious doubt on loan repayment feasibility.
  2. Violation of “Nuclear Public Disclosure Guidelines" and Hollowing Out of Environmental Guidelines
    • Environmental Impact Statements (EIS) are publicly available on the JBIC/NEXI websites for only one of the ten projects (Clinch River Unit 1), violating the agencies’ Nuclear Public Disclosure Guidelines, which mandate the disclosure and review of site/construction plans, waste management plans, and environmental assessments.
    • Under JBIC/NEXI environmental guidelines, conducting environmental reviews after financial decisions based on EIS documents is designated as “exceptional" and clearly does not apply to these nuclear power projects.
  3. Serious Environmental, Social, and Safety/Waste Management Concerns
    • The publicly available EIS for Clinch River Unit 1 reveals concerns such as river water temperature increases and impacts on aquatic ecosystems and endangered species due to massive water intake/discharge, cumulative impacts in a region dense with nuclear/weapons facilities dating back to the Manhattan Project, and disproportionate risks to local minority and low-income communities.
    • Significant uncertainties remain, including public safety concerns from massive reductions in Emergency Planning Zones (EPZ) for unproven SMR designs, the lack of a permanent high-level radioactive waste repository in the U.S., and insufficient comparisons with alternatives such as solar and storage batteries.
  4. The Legal Basis for the Underlying Trump Tariff Has Collapsed—Renegotiation Is Needed
    • The U.S. Courts ruled the tariff measures by Trump underpinning this investment package illegal, including the U.S. Supreme Court’s February ruling invalidating tariffs under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA), and the U.S. Court of International Trade (CIT) ruling against Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974.
    • If fully government-owned institutions like JBIC and NEXI shoulder massive risks, it will directly lead to taxpayer-funded bailouts in Japan. Now that the legal foundation for the tariffs has been called into question, the framework for U.S. investment must be scrapped and renegotiated.

Signatory Organizations:

  • Friends of the Earth Japan
  • Citizens’ Nuclear Information Center
  • Citizens’ Commission on Nuclear Energy
  • Green Action
  • Japan Center for a Sustainable Environment and Society (JACSES)
  • Friends of the Earth United States
  • Nuclear Information and Resource Service 
  • Beyond Nuclear
  • 350.org Japan
  • Peace Boat
  • Peace Boat US

High-Risk US SMR Financing Puts Japanese Public Funds and Taxpayers in Jeopardy

Failure to Comply with Public Disclosure Rules and Serious Concerns Over Loan Repayment

On October 23, the Japan Bank for International Cooperation (JBIC) and Nippon Export and Investment Insurance (NEXI) added 10 projects to their respective lists of projects under consideration for support, published on their websites[1]. These include Units 1–5 of the Clinch River Nuclear Power Plant in Tennessee and Units 5–9 of the Bellefonte Nuclear Power Plant in Alabama. A decision on financial support can be made in 45 days of the disclosure of information on the project list.

These projects fall under the “second tranche" (totaling approximately 10 trillion yen) of Japan’s investment package for the US, amounting to a total of $550 billion (approx. 86 trillion yen), agreed upon as a result of US-Japan tariff negotiations. All of these projects are planned to utilize GE Vernova Hitachi Small Modular Reactors (SMRs, model: BWRX-300). The total amount is estimated to be up to $40 billion (approx. 6 trillion yen).

We oppose the financial support by JBIC and NEXI for these nuclear projects for the following reasons:

1. Lack of Economic Rationale

Of the 10 projects, only one project obtained construction permits, and the planned reactor model, the BWRX-300, has not secured standard design approval from the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Delays in obtaining construction permits and prolonged reviews inflate construction costs and delay projects.

The economic rationale for SMRs is questionable. Although advertised as “small and inexpensive," they tend to be more costly per unit of electricity generated than existing large-scale nuclear plants (for details, see the statement: “Statement: The Second Tranche of US Investment Risking Japanese Public Funds and Taxpayers is Unacceptable," issued March 19, 2026). The SMR project in Idaho  (CFPP) by US-based NuScale Power, which seemed to have had some progress ahead of others, was also forced to be canceled in November 2023 due to soaring construction costs.[2] At a time when the cost of renewable energy is plunging globally, investing in high-cost SMRs with no business case will leave serious doubts about repayment feasibility.

2. Non-compliance with JBIC/NEXI’s “Nuclear Information Disclosure Guidelines" and Hollowed-Out Environmental Guidelines

Out of the 10 projects, only one project – Unit 1 of the Clinch River Nuclear Power Plant –  has an environmental impact assessment report and is available on JBIC and NEXI’s website. This violates JBIC and NEXI’s “Guidelines for Confirmation of Information Disclosure Considerations for Nuclear Sector Projects" (hereinafter, “Nuclear Information Disclosure Guidelines"). The Nuclear Information Disclosure Guidelines designate “plans to site and build a facility," “spent fuel and radioactive waste management plans," “environmental and social impact assessments," and “emergency preparedness and emergency response plans" as subjects for information disclosure, and prescribe that “In principle, the provision of such information is to be reviewed by JBIC prior to making decisions for Funding." Although there is an exception provision stating that “the provision of information that is difficult to confirm at the time of the decision making such as “notification and evacuation procedures” and “plans for operational safety” is to be monitored," there is no provision allowing loan decisions to be made without disclosing any information regarding “plans to site and build a facility," “spent fuel and radioactive waste management plans," and “environmental and social impact assessments".

In principle, JBIC/NEXI environmental guidelines require that for projects with serious and undesirable environmental impacts such as nuclear power generation, environmental reviews based on environmental impact assessment reports would be conducted by JBIC and NEXI themselves prior to their decision-making. Recent revisions to the guidelines added that “in exceptional cases where, given the nature of the project, documents necessary for environmental reviews are not available at the time that a decision on the funding must be made, JBIC may make a decision on the funding on the condition that it will undertake the environmental reviews after decision making.”  but this is designated as “exceptional". Examples of applicable cases for exemption could include “acquisition of rights and interests in the early stages of natural resource development projects, or equity participation projects in which decision making is required in the stages where specific use of funds is not determined,"[3] but nuclear power generation projects clearly do not fall under these cases.

Permitting JBIC and NEXI to exercise arbitrary judgments under such vaguely defined “exceptions"—devoid of accountability and transparency—must not be tolerated. If an environmental review is postponed until after financial decisions are made, it becomes virtually impossible to take remedial actions such as suspending loan disbursements or demanding early repayment, even if major environmental and social issues are uncovered at that stage, thereby completely hollowing out the environmental guidelines.

3. Environmental and Social Concerns and Numerous Uncertainties

The following concerns can be read from the currently published Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) and related documents for Clinch River Nuclear Power Plant Unit 1.

  • Large-volume water intake from and discharge into the river raise concerns about the effects of rising water temperatures on aquatic ecosystems (fish and benthic organisms), and about maintaining cooling capacity during periods of low river flow. As climate change worsens water temperature rise and drought risk, the cumulative impact will become more serious if multiple SMRs and similar facilities are concentrated.
    •  Impacts on endangered species such as freshwater mussels, the Indiana bat, and the northern long-eared bat are a concern.
  • The Clinch River site area is also a region densely packed with nuclear and weapons-related facilities, such as the Y-12 National Security Complex, which dates back to the  Manhattan Project. The area has long carried risks of contamination and management of radioactive waste and hazardous substances, so a cumulative impact assessment is needed before adding a new group of nuclear facilities to an area that has already suffered from contamination and management risks of radioactive waste and hazardous substances for many years. There are also concerns that environmental, livelihood, radiation exposure, and accident risks will be imposed on surrounding areas and on minority and low-income communities.
    • The project developer (Tennessee Valley Authority: TVA) sought and was granted a significant reduction in the scope of the Emergency Planning Zone (EPZ) to the vicinity of the site boundary, citing the inherent safety of SMRs (such as passive safety features) compared to conventional large reactors.[4] However, there are many uncertainties regarding the safety of unproven SMRs, and in the unlikely event of a severe accident, evacuation plans for surrounding residents, information dissemination, and public protection measures could be kept to a minimum, and there is a risk that residents’ safety and health will not be protected.

Many uncertainties also remain:

  • Energy alternatives, project necessity, and cost-benefit are unclear. For instance, it has been pointed out[5] that there is no adequate quantitative comparison with solar combined with battery storage (whose costs are falling rapidly), grid reinforcement, and demand response, and that the cost-escalation risk specific to a first commercial unit is being ignored.
  • Regarding spent nuclear fuel, the US still has no permanent disposal site for high-level radioactive waste since the Yucca Mountain project stalled.[6] Where and how the radioactive waste generated from this project will be managed and disposed of over the long term, and who will be responsible, remain unclear at this stage.
  • Many recent nuclear plant constructions in the US have suffered huge cost overruns and serious construction delays, which in some cases have driven up regional electricity rates. The same could happen with this project, with a major negative impact on the local economy.

4. The Legal Basis for the Underlying Tariff Increases Has Collapsed—Renegotiation Is Needed

This series of massive US investment plans emerged as a political concession to avert tariff pressure from the United States.

The legal basis for the tariff measures underlying the US agreement has been collapsing one after another in the courts. In February this year, the US Supreme Court ruled tariffs under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) were illegal[7], and the tariffs the administration put forward as a replacement under Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974 were also judged illegal by the US Court of International Trade (CIT)[8].  TheTrump administration’s trade and tariff policies rest on a legally vulnerable foundation and are strongly criticized within the US for accelerating inflation. Pushing ahead in quick succession with an investment package involving massive public funds (including nuclear projects) therefore poses incalculable financial and political risks to Japan.

JBIC, which plays a central role in lending and investment, and NEXI, which provides guarantees to private banks, are public financial institutions wholly owned by the Japanese government. The investment is very large relative to the outstanding loan and guarantee balances of both institutions, and the government has already appropriated funds to strengthen their financial foundations. Fiscal base reinforcement expenses for both institutions. The risk that public funds will have to be injected if the projects fail is clear.

Now that the legal basis for the tariff increases has been shaken, the framework for US investment and financing should be scrapped and renegotiated from scratch.

As environmental NGOs and civil society organizations, we strongly oppose the investment of large amounts of public funds in US SMR projects, which are dubious in terms of economic rationality and repayment feasibility, entail major environmental and social impacts, and carry high risks of radioactive contamination and nuclear proliferation.

Signatory Organizations:

  • Friends of the Earth Japan
  • Citizens’ Nuclear Information Center
  • Citizens’ Commission on Nuclear Energy
  • Green Action
  • Japan Center for a Sustainable Environment and Society (JACSES)
  • Friends of the Earth United States
  • Nuclear Information and Resource Service
  • Beyond Nuclear
  • 350.org Japan
  • Peace Boat
  • Peace Boat US

[1] Projects Already Classified into One of the Environmental Categories and Currently under Screening Process | JBIC Japan Bank for International Cooperation , Information on Screening Results|Environment|NEXI Nippon Export and Investment Insurance

[2] Utah Associated Municipal Power Systems (UAMPS) and NuScale Power Agree to Terminate the Carbon Free Power Project (CFPP)

IEEFA, Eye-popping new cost estimates released for NuScale small modular reactor,January 11, 2023

[3] FAQ https://www.jbic.go.jp/en/business-areas/image/faq_en.pdf p.17

[4] Clinch River Nuclear Site, Early Site Permit Application, Part 6, Exemptions and Departures, Revision 2

[5] U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), Environmental Impact Statement for an Early Site Permit (ESP) at the Clinch River Nuclear Site, Final Report (NUREG-2226), Vol. 2, Appendix E (“Comments Received on the Environmental Review")

[6] Ibid.

[7] Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, 607 U.S. 229 (2026)

[8] State of Oregon v. United States, Slip Op. 26-47 (Ct. Int’l Trade May 7, 2026).